Shrimp Cocktail, Done Right: Everything You Need to Know

By Broad Street Oyster Co.

Shrimp Cocktail, Done Right: Everything You Need to Know

Shrimp cocktail is one of the great classics. It's simple, it's satisfying, and it's the perfect way to start a seafood meal, especially for anyone who's still working up the nerve to try raw oysters.

What makes a great shrimp cocktail

  • Big shrimp: jumbo shrimp have the sweet, meaty bite you want.
  • Cooked just right: firm and snappy, never rubbery.
  • Served ice cold: shrimp cocktail should be chilled all the way through.
  • A bright, punchy sauce: tangy cocktail sauce with a real kick of horseradish.
  • Lemon on the side: a squeeze brightens everything.

How to eat it

Hold the shrimp by the tail, dip it in the sauce, and bite. Leave the tail behind. Double-dipping is between you and your table.

Why it's the perfect starter

Shrimp cocktail is light, so it won't fill you up before the main event. It's also an easy crowd-pleaser: guests who aren't sure about oysters almost always love shrimp. At our restaurants, it's a natural partner for a dozen oysters and a World Famous Lobster Roll.

What to drink with it

A Bloody Mary is the classic pairing; it practically has cocktail sauce built in. A cold beer, a crisp white wine or a glass of rosé are great too. See more ideas in our guide to what to drink with seafood.

Shrimp cocktail for a party

Shrimp cocktail is one of the easiest things to serve a crowd. Pile it on ice next to oysters and you have the start of a raw bar. Planning one? Read our tips on how to host a raw bar party at home, or let us handle it: our catering includes wild-caught jumbo shrimp cocktail, and we bring it just about anywhere. Email events@broadstreetoyster.com.

Order it at Broad Street Oyster Co.

Find shrimp cocktail on the raw bar in Malibu, at the Huntington Beach Pier, in Santa Barbara and at Grand Central Market.

Back to blog