How to Eat Oysters: A Beginner's Guide to the Raw Bar
By Broad Street Oyster Co.
Oysters have a reputation for being intimidating. They shouldn't. Once you know a few simple steps, eating oysters on the half shell is one of the easiest (and most fun) ways to start a meal. Here's how we do it at Broad Street Oyster Co.
What you'll get
Raw oysters come shucked and served on the half shell over ice. The shucker has already cut the oyster loose from its shell, so all you have to do is eat it. Most raw bars, including ours, serve them with lemon and mignonette, a classic sauce of vinegar, shallots and cracked pepper.
How to eat an oyster, step by step
- Pick it up by the wide end. Hold the shell level so you don't spill the liquid inside. That liquid, called the liquor, is part of the flavor.
- Check that it's loose. Run the little fork under the oyster to make sure it's free from the shell.
- Dress it lightly. A squeeze of lemon, a small spoonful of mignonette or a drop of hot sauce. Start with less than you think; you want to taste the oyster.
- Tip it back. Bring the wide end to your lips and slide the oyster and its liquor into your mouth.
- Chew once or twice. This is where the flavor is: briny first, then sweet, creamy or mineral depending on the oyster. Swallowing it whole skips the best part.
- Flip the shell. At a lot of raw bars, turning the empty shell upside down is a quiet way of saying "done."
What to put on them
- Lemon: brightens the brine. The classic starting point.
- Mignonette: tangy and sharp. Our favorite way to eat them.
- Hot sauce: a drop, not a puddle.
- Nothing at all: the purist's choice, and worth trying at least once.
What to drink with oysters
Crisp, cold and a little salty works best. A glass of white wine or bubbles, a cold beer, or a michelada all pair well. The goal is something that refreshes between oysters rather than covering them up.
Make it a meal
Oysters are the perfect opener. From there, go for a World Famous Lobster Roll (warm with butter or chilled with mayo), shrimp cocktail, or the seafood tower if you're sharing. For a big table, start with a dozen oysters for every two or three people and order more as you go.
Oyster FAQ
Do I have to eat oysters only in months with an "R"? That old rule comes from before refrigeration and modern oyster farming. Today, oysters are enjoyed year-round.
How many should I order? Half a dozen per person is a good start for a first round.
Are raw oysters safe? Raw oysters are a delicacy, but eating raw or undercooked shellfish may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions. If you're unsure, check with your doctor before ordering.
Try them at a raw bar near you
Pull up a stool at any Broad Street Oyster Co. location: Malibu, Huntington Beach Pier, Santa Barbara or Grand Central Market. Hosting a party? We can bring the raw bar to you, shuckers included. Email events@broadstreetoyster.com.